Bob McCahill: Heaving The Iron Pellet

Bob McCahill, class of 1938, was one of the great Bay athletes of the early years.  Bob was at minimum a nine-time letterman, earning three each in football, basketball and track.  He was All-Suburban in football as a senior and in the fourth Glory Cup game scored the winning PAT on a line plunge, 7-6 Bays.  In track, he was a key member of the 1937 Bay team that was the first to win a State title, winning the Shot Put and placing fourth in the Discus at Camp Randall.  His two wins at State as a senior in 1938 enabled the Bay to pull out a close one, 22 to 18 over Shawano and South Milwaukee.  His Class B Shot Put record was not broken until 1945.

Capture (3)


In action at Camp Randall in 1938:

Capture - Copy


After his graduation from the Bay, Bob’s parents moved to Pittsburgh, PA, while Bob stayed in Milwaukee to attend Marquette University.  He was a multi-year starter in football for the Hilltoppers and played a key role in what is arguably Marquette’s greatest ever football win:  a 28-7 thrashing at Camp Randall in 1941 of a heavily favored Wisconsin squad that featured Pat Harder and Dave Schreiner.  He also won three track letters at Marquette.

McCahill 1


The NFL’s Cleveland Rams beckoned in March, 1942.

McCahill - Rams


Graduation from Marquette in June, 1942:

Capture (5)

Capture1 - Copy


He enlisted in the Marine Corps immediately after graduation, attended Marine Corps Officer Candidate School in Quantico, VA and later trained as a Parachute Specialist.



Bob was stationed in the Pacific Theater from March, 1943 to February, 1944 and saw significant action in the Solomon Islands campaign.  He was then re-assigned stateside for six months before again being stationed in the Pacific Theater with the 27th Marine Regiment.  While stateside, he married fellow Marquette graduate Nancy Van Roo on March 21, 1944 at St. Monica’s Catholic Church in Whitefish Bay.

The_Pittsburgh_Press_Thu__Mar_30__1944_ - Copy


Bob was part of the first wave of the Iwo Jima invasion force and died on February 20, 1945 in the battle for control of Airfield No. 1 (South Field), a critical first day objective.  He was buried at sea.



Whitefish Bay Herald, March, 1945:

Death Notice


His name is listed on the Courts of the Missing at National Memorial Cemetery of the Pacific in Honolulu, HI.

56124748_1394207877 - Copy


Mr. and Mrs. McCahill established the Robert L. McCahill Award at Marquette in 1946.  Bob’s older brother Bill was in the first Bay graduating class in 1934 and had also been an outstanding athlete at Marquette, so after Bill passed away in 1999 the award was renamed by the McCahill family to also honor Bill.  The McCahill Award is a big deal in the Marquette athletic community.



Did you ever stop to read the plaque that’s in the corridor outside the Memorial Gym?  If so, you’re one up on me.



Nancy Van Roo McCahill remarried, had a family and was a long-time teacher in the Wauwatosa public school system.

In 1961 a marker in Bob’s memory was placed at Arlington National Cemetery.

22603756_119396200682 - Copy


Before the Marquette and Marine Corps days, Bob was an awkward high school kid just like the rest of us, judging by what he wrote as a sophomore in a classmate’s 1936 Tower:



3 thoughts on “Bob McCahill: Heaving The Iron Pellet

  1. I enjoyed reading this and am grateful to whoever cared enough to research and post it! Through Bob’s parents (my grandparents), his brother (my father), and Bob’s widow Nancy, we (the family) heard details over the years of what a fine son, brother, husband, and Marine he was, a standout in several sports at Whitefish Bay and then at Marquette for football and track, but there’s much wonderful detail here that I’ve never seen.
    Kind regards,
    Robert J. McCahill, nephew of Robert L. McCahill, and son of RLMcC’s brother William P. McCahill.
    Vienna, VA


    1. Bob:

      Thank you for your kind words. A story like this pretty much writes itself. It was luck that I even stumbled on it. I was looking through the list of individual state champions on the WIAA website and then a day or two later accidentally came across the list of names on the WWII memorial plaque (that I barely remembered existed). “Wait, I’ve seen that name before.” And then the research was the fun part, except that with each new piece of information I found the ending always stayed the same.

      Something else that I found that I didn’t include above was that your father was the one who requested that a marker for Bob be placed at Arlington National Cemetery. It was a great gesture on your father’s part and, obviously, Bob deserved to be recognized at Arlington.

      Thank you again. It’s nice to know that what was written was appreciated.



  2. The WFB Historic Preservation Commission would like to use this wonderful story in Bay Leaves, the village newsletter. Baystrack would receive full credit. Do we have your OK? And who should we credit for this beautifully written piece? Jeff Aikin, Chair, WFBHPC 962-3709


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s